By: neel123

neel123 — Mon, 09 Aug 2010 17:46:34 +0000

Giddar Ki Jab Maut Aati Hai, Shaher Ke Taraf Bhaag ta Hai …….. !

These misguided madrasa educated muslims are just courting disaster for themselves ……… while the community is watching as a by-stander ……… !

By: Mukesh G Awasthi

Mukesh G Awasthi — Mon, 09 Aug 2010 01:12:40 +0000

I appreciate you article, whic I found to be an eye opener, but nevertheless, I have a fwe comments to make, with your permission and for your considerations and response, if you please.
I choose to omit the opositive portions of your article, so please do not mind if my comments are somewhat one-sided.
Since I am highly interested in Islam, I have been reading about it and have been influenced by the stance of the Deoband madarsa.
You have said in you article: “Their wish of martyrdom and meeting the houris can be fulfilled sooner than later there. …”.
I have read a hadith in the book Muslim Shareef which says: “If a person dies, without ever wishing to have participated in Jihad…he dies on Nifak…”
In your article, you seem to be ascrbing the Jihad wish to thoise whom you critcise, which pre-supposes that you yourself do not wish to ever participate in Jihad. This itself makes you a Munafiik?
Is my understanding correct? I have tried to get my respnse verified from the respectable scholars, but most seem to shy away from responding on such an issue.
w
Will you please correct me, I hope to get my commented corrected/modifeid, but only in the lkight of an textual evidence.

Comments on: Khilafat In India: Who Are These Mysterious Jihadis?

By: neel123

By: Mukesh G Awasthi